20/02/2009
Thompson Made 'Reasonable' Decision On Gaza Appeal
BBC Director-General Mark Thompson made a "reasonable" decision in deciding not to broadcast an humanitarian aid appeal for Gaza, the BBC Trust has ruled.
ITV, Channel 4 and Channel Five showed the Disasters Emergency Committee aid appeal. However, the BBC, along with Sky News, did not air the appeal, stating that it might compromise impartiality to do so.
Mr Thompson's decision sparked angry protests and 40,000 complaints to the BBC.
A statement issued by the BBC Trust said that it would not overrule on appeal the Director-General's decision against broadcasting the appeal.
Sir Michael Lyons, Chairman of the Trust, said: "We recognise that the Director-General's decision was a matter of great controversy for many members of the public. However, having carefully examined the Director-General's reasons, the Trust believes he acted correctly throughout, and we are satisfied that the decision the Director-General took was reasonable given the importance of preserving the reputation of the BBC for impartiality."
Sir Michael stressed that, under the BBC Charter, the Director-General was Editor-in-Chief of the BBC and it was not in the Trust's remit "to second-guess his editorial decisions, nor should it be". He said: "Our role is to ensure he reaches those decisions with care, and free from undue influence from any quarter. What we reviewed was whether the handling of the request for the DEC appeal complied with the relevant processes, policy and guidelines; and whether the decision reached by the Director-General was within the parameters of reasonable decisions open to him.
"On the handling point, we find that the Director-General acted correctly, sought the appropriate advice, and gave proper consideration to the views of the public and those of DEC.
"On the reasonableness point, the Director-General argued that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is deeply divisive and that the suffering of civilians plays a central part in the political case each side makes in the 'court of world opinion'; consequently it is impossible in this case to separate the political causes from their humanitarian consequences. "
Sir Michael said that the question of this appeal would not be re-opened, but said that the Trust was "mindful of the degree of public concern it aroused". He said: "We have therefore asked the Director-General to explore any wider lessons that may be drawn from this episode through discussions with DEC and with other broadcasters.
"In particular, we have asked him to take a view on whether the BBC agreement with DEC, which dates from 1971, and the associated criteria for considering appeals, are still appropriate for today's changed conditions."
(KMcA/JM)
ITV, Channel 4 and Channel Five showed the Disasters Emergency Committee aid appeal. However, the BBC, along with Sky News, did not air the appeal, stating that it might compromise impartiality to do so.
Mr Thompson's decision sparked angry protests and 40,000 complaints to the BBC.
A statement issued by the BBC Trust said that it would not overrule on appeal the Director-General's decision against broadcasting the appeal.
Sir Michael Lyons, Chairman of the Trust, said: "We recognise that the Director-General's decision was a matter of great controversy for many members of the public. However, having carefully examined the Director-General's reasons, the Trust believes he acted correctly throughout, and we are satisfied that the decision the Director-General took was reasonable given the importance of preserving the reputation of the BBC for impartiality."
Sir Michael stressed that, under the BBC Charter, the Director-General was Editor-in-Chief of the BBC and it was not in the Trust's remit "to second-guess his editorial decisions, nor should it be". He said: "Our role is to ensure he reaches those decisions with care, and free from undue influence from any quarter. What we reviewed was whether the handling of the request for the DEC appeal complied with the relevant processes, policy and guidelines; and whether the decision reached by the Director-General was within the parameters of reasonable decisions open to him.
"On the handling point, we find that the Director-General acted correctly, sought the appropriate advice, and gave proper consideration to the views of the public and those of DEC.
"On the reasonableness point, the Director-General argued that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is deeply divisive and that the suffering of civilians plays a central part in the political case each side makes in the 'court of world opinion'; consequently it is impossible in this case to separate the political causes from their humanitarian consequences. "
Sir Michael said that the question of this appeal would not be re-opened, but said that the Trust was "mindful of the degree of public concern it aroused". He said: "We have therefore asked the Director-General to explore any wider lessons that may be drawn from this episode through discussions with DEC and with other broadcasters.
"In particular, we have asked him to take a view on whether the BBC agreement with DEC, which dates from 1971, and the associated criteria for considering appeals, are still appropriate for today's changed conditions."
(KMcA/JM)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
30 January 2004
Dyke scores line in Hutton mud
Former BBC Director-General Greg Dyke has said that he was shocked that the Hutton Report was "so black and white" and has claimed that the report's conclusions were "quite clearly wrong". In an outspoken interview on GMTV Mr Dyke also attacked Tony Blair's former press chief Alastair Campbell for being "remarkably ungracious".
Dyke scores line in Hutton mud
Former BBC Director-General Greg Dyke has said that he was shocked that the Hutton Report was "so black and white" and has claimed that the report's conclusions were "quite clearly wrong". In an outspoken interview on GMTV Mr Dyke also attacked Tony Blair's former press chief Alastair Campbell for being "remarkably ungracious".
08 March 2004
BBC begins search for Director-General
The BBC has advertised for a successor to Greg Dyke, following his resignation as Director General in the wake of the Hutton Report. This follows the start last week of a search for a new BBC Chairman, a position whose previous incumbent, Gavyn Davies, was another post-Hutton casualty.
BBC begins search for Director-General
The BBC has advertised for a successor to Greg Dyke, following his resignation as Director General in the wake of the Hutton Report. This follows the start last week of a search for a new BBC Chairman, a position whose previous incumbent, Gavyn Davies, was another post-Hutton casualty.
27 May 2011
Trust Launches Review Of BBC News Channel And BBC Parliament
The BBC Trust has launched its service review of BBC Parliament and BBC News Channel, as part of its rolling programme of service reviews. The review will look at the current performance of BBC Parliament and the News Channel - including the stations' quality, distinctiveness and value for money - and the BBC's future plans for the services.
Trust Launches Review Of BBC News Channel And BBC Parliament
The BBC Trust has launched its service review of BBC Parliament and BBC News Channel, as part of its rolling programme of service reviews. The review will look at the current performance of BBC Parliament and the News Channel - including the stations' quality, distinctiveness and value for money - and the BBC's future plans for the services.
16 March 2012
BBC To Move Forward With Paid Download Service
The BBC's director of archive content Roly Keating has said viewers are “very comfortable” with the corporations plans to launch an iTunes-style download service.
BBC To Move Forward With Paid Download Service
The BBC's director of archive content Roly Keating has said viewers are “very comfortable” with the corporations plans to launch an iTunes-style download service.
22 May 2006
WHO head dies
Lee Jong-wook, Director-General of the United Nations World Health Organisation, has died after a short illness, aged 61. Dr Lee, who became Director-General of the 192-member WHO in July 2003, had been in hospital in Geneva since Saturday afternoon, where he underwent surgery to remove a blood clot on his brain.
WHO head dies
Lee Jong-wook, Director-General of the United Nations World Health Organisation, has died after a short illness, aged 61. Dr Lee, who became Director-General of the 192-member WHO in July 2003, had been in hospital in Geneva since Saturday afternoon, where he underwent surgery to remove a blood clot on his brain.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:After a dry start this morning rain will spread from the northwest across all parts. This afternoon will be dull with some patchy rain and drizzle. Becoming much milder through the afternoon. Maximum temperature 11 °C.Tonight:A cloudy evening and night with a little light rain or drizzle, perhaps some clear periods developing along the east coast. A very mild night everywhere. Minimum temperature 10 °C.