Menu
19/02/2009
MS Sufferer Loses Assisted Suicide Appeal Case
A multiple sclerosis sufferer has lost her Appeal Court case to get the law on assisted suicide clarified.
Debbie Purdy, 45, wanted to know if her husband Omar Puente would be prosecuted if he helped her travel abroad to help her die.
However, three appeal judges ruled Ms Purdy was not legally entitled to the kind of specific guidance she is seeking.
The 45-year-old, from Undercliffe, Bradford, West Yorkshire, was diagnosed with primary progressive MS in 1995 and can no longer walk.
In England and Wales, aiding and abetting suicide is a criminal offence punishable by up to 14 years in prison.
The High Court ruled the Code of Practice for Crown Prosecutions already issued by the Director of Public Prosecutions, coupled with the general safeguards of administrative law, satisfied human rights laws and provided the necessary clarity.
Lord Chief Justice Lord Judge and two other appeal judges, Lord Justice Lloyd and Lord Justice Ward, ruled that further official guidance is not necessary.
They said: "Not withstanding our sympathy for the dreadful predicament in which Ms Purdy and Mr Puente find themselves, this appeal must be dismissed."
Ms Purdy claims however, that the law is unclear and unless it is made more obvious, she could be forced into travelling earlier because her Cuban violinist husband would not be able to assist her without risking imprisonment.
Ms Purdy says she is "disappointed and shocked" at their decision.
(JM/BMcC)
Debbie Purdy, 45, wanted to know if her husband Omar Puente would be prosecuted if he helped her travel abroad to help her die.
However, three appeal judges ruled Ms Purdy was not legally entitled to the kind of specific guidance she is seeking.
The 45-year-old, from Undercliffe, Bradford, West Yorkshire, was diagnosed with primary progressive MS in 1995 and can no longer walk.
In England and Wales, aiding and abetting suicide is a criminal offence punishable by up to 14 years in prison.
The High Court ruled the Code of Practice for Crown Prosecutions already issued by the Director of Public Prosecutions, coupled with the general safeguards of administrative law, satisfied human rights laws and provided the necessary clarity.
Lord Chief Justice Lord Judge and two other appeal judges, Lord Justice Lloyd and Lord Justice Ward, ruled that further official guidance is not necessary.
They said: "Not withstanding our sympathy for the dreadful predicament in which Ms Purdy and Mr Puente find themselves, this appeal must be dismissed."
Ms Purdy claims however, that the law is unclear and unless it is made more obvious, she could be forced into travelling earlier because her Cuban violinist husband would not be able to assist her without risking imprisonment.
Ms Purdy says she is "disappointed and shocked" at their decision.
(JM/BMcC)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
29 October 2008
MS Sufferer Loses Assisted Suicide Challenge
A multiple sclerosis sufferer, who went to the High Court in an attempt to clarify the law on assisted suicide, has lost her legal bid. Debbie Purdy, 45, from Bradford had planned to travel to an assisted suicide clinic in Switzerland, however she had gone to court to ensure her husband would not be prosecuted on his return to the UK.
MS Sufferer Loses Assisted Suicide Challenge
A multiple sclerosis sufferer, who went to the High Court in an attempt to clarify the law on assisted suicide, has lost her legal bid. Debbie Purdy, 45, from Bradford had planned to travel to an assisted suicide clinic in Switzerland, however she had gone to court to ensure her husband would not be prosecuted on his return to the UK.
27 August 2013
MS And Parkinson's Sufferers Told They Are Fit To Work
Almost half of people with some progressive conditions, including Parkinson's, who put in a claim for the sickness benefit Employment and Support Allowance (ESA), are being told they will recover enough to look for work in the future.
MS And Parkinson's Sufferers Told They Are Fit To Work
Almost half of people with some progressive conditions, including Parkinson's, who put in a claim for the sickness benefit Employment and Support Allowance (ESA), are being told they will recover enough to look for work in the future.
28 February 2014
Police Renew Appeal For Missing Nida Naseer
Police still have no information on the whereabouts of a 19-year-old woman who disappeared from outside her home while putting the bins out. Nida Naseer has not been seen since around 20:00 on Saturday 28 December. Ms Naseer was not wearing shoes and did not have her phone, money or coat with her when she disappeared.
Police Renew Appeal For Missing Nida Naseer
Police still have no information on the whereabouts of a 19-year-old woman who disappeared from outside her home while putting the bins out. Nida Naseer has not been seen since around 20:00 on Saturday 28 December. Ms Naseer was not wearing shoes and did not have her phone, money or coat with her when she disappeared.
20 March 2012
Pregnant Woman Wins Extradition Appeal
As a result of prison conditions in Argentina a woman due to give birth in May has avoided being extradited to face dugs charges. Arrested in Buenos Aires in 2007 while carrying over 6kg of cocaine, Lucy Wright, successfully argued at the High Court that being extradited would breach her human rights.
Pregnant Woman Wins Extradition Appeal
As a result of prison conditions in Argentina a woman due to give birth in May has avoided being extradited to face dugs charges. Arrested in Buenos Aires in 2007 while carrying over 6kg of cocaine, Lucy Wright, successfully argued at the High Court that being extradited would breach her human rights.
27 May 2011
Shoesmith Wins Appeal Over Baby P Sacking
Having won an appeal following her sacking over the death of Baby Peter in 2007, ex-children's services director, Sharon Shoesmith has said she is "thrilled". Ms Shoesmith challenged the High Court ruling that cleared Ed Balls, former children's secretary, and Haringey Council for acting unlawfully.
Shoesmith Wins Appeal Over Baby P Sacking
Having won an appeal following her sacking over the death of Baby Peter in 2007, ex-children's services director, Sharon Shoesmith has said she is "thrilled". Ms Shoesmith challenged the High Court ruling that cleared Ed Balls, former children's secretary, and Haringey Council for acting unlawfully.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:Gale, coastal severe gale, northwest winds ease from late afternoon. Scattered showers will fall as snow over the hills at first, becoming isolated from mid-afternoon. Maximum temperature 7 °C.Tonight:Showers, scattered in the evening, will clear by midnight leaving the night dry with clear spells. Cloud will spread east towards morning. Minimum temperature 2 °C.
