Menu
12/08/2008
Rape Victim Wins Appeal Over 'Booze' Compensation Cut
A woman who suffered rape five years ago has successfully opposed a decision to have her compensation cut by a quarter - because she had been drinking.
The victim, who was 25 when she was raped, had been originally told by the Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority (CICA) that the standard £11,000 award would be cut to £8,250 because she was drinking before the attack took place.
The woman, who cannot be named for legal reasons, said the decision to cut her award "felt like a slap in the face".
The CICA said that the reason for the reduction was that "the evidence shows that your excessive consumption of alcohol was a contributing factor in the incident".
The woman, whose attacker has never been caught, had also complained to the Metropolitan Police about the way her case was handled.
Her complaint resulted in two members of the force being disciplined and an offer of apology to the victim.
Her lawyer, Debaleena Dasgupta, successfully argued that it was wrong to regard alcohol consumption as a contributing factor in rape cases as it implied that the victim was in some way responsible.
Ms Dasgupta said she had been "appalled" by the decision.
"It was immoral. My immediate reaction was there has got to be some way to fight this," she said.
The CICA acknowledged its rules had been applied wrongly in 14 other cases, where compensation awards had been cut because the victims had been drinking.
Ms Dasgupta's client has now won the full £11,000 award.
Lisa Longstaff, of Women Against Rape, said the original decision by the CICA was "symptomatic of the blame culture" experience by rape victims.
Ms Longstaff said "it's very important for women who've been victims of rape to get compensation because often it's the only acknowledgement you are going to get that you have been a victim of crime, given that the conviction rate in this country is only 6%".
A spokesman for the CICA said "a review of our staff instructions, operating procedures and structure" had been completed to "ensure greater consistency in decision making".
Justice Minister Bridget Prentice said: "It is not our policy to reduce the level of award to a victim or rape due to alcoholic consumption.
"It is never an individual's fault if he/she get raped; regardless of how much he/she has drunk," she said.
The CICA deals with around 60,000 rape cases a year.
(DS)
The victim, who was 25 when she was raped, had been originally told by the Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority (CICA) that the standard £11,000 award would be cut to £8,250 because she was drinking before the attack took place.
The woman, who cannot be named for legal reasons, said the decision to cut her award "felt like a slap in the face".
The CICA said that the reason for the reduction was that "the evidence shows that your excessive consumption of alcohol was a contributing factor in the incident".
The woman, whose attacker has never been caught, had also complained to the Metropolitan Police about the way her case was handled.
Her complaint resulted in two members of the force being disciplined and an offer of apology to the victim.
Her lawyer, Debaleena Dasgupta, successfully argued that it was wrong to regard alcohol consumption as a contributing factor in rape cases as it implied that the victim was in some way responsible.
Ms Dasgupta said she had been "appalled" by the decision.
"It was immoral. My immediate reaction was there has got to be some way to fight this," she said.
The CICA acknowledged its rules had been applied wrongly in 14 other cases, where compensation awards had been cut because the victims had been drinking.
Ms Dasgupta's client has now won the full £11,000 award.
Lisa Longstaff, of Women Against Rape, said the original decision by the CICA was "symptomatic of the blame culture" experience by rape victims.
Ms Longstaff said "it's very important for women who've been victims of rape to get compensation because often it's the only acknowledgement you are going to get that you have been a victim of crime, given that the conviction rate in this country is only 6%".
A spokesman for the CICA said "a review of our staff instructions, operating procedures and structure" had been completed to "ensure greater consistency in decision making".
Justice Minister Bridget Prentice said: "It is not our policy to reduce the level of award to a victim or rape due to alcoholic consumption.
"It is never an individual's fault if he/she get raped; regardless of how much he/she has drunk," she said.
The CICA deals with around 60,000 rape cases a year.
(DS)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
06 January 2015
Rape Investigation Against MP Mark Pritchard Dropped
An investigation into rape allegations against Conservative MP Mark Pritchard have been dropped, Scotland Yard has confirmed. Mr Pritchard, MP for The Wrekin in Shropshire, was arrested on 2 December, however he was released on police bail. He has now been informed no further action will be taken.
Rape Investigation Against MP Mark Pritchard Dropped
An investigation into rape allegations against Conservative MP Mark Pritchard have been dropped, Scotland Yard has confirmed. Mr Pritchard, MP for The Wrekin in Shropshire, was arrested on 2 December, however he was released on police bail. He has now been informed no further action will be taken.
22 June 2012
Rochdale Paedophile Ringleader Named
The ringleader of a paedophile gang in Rochdale, who groomed young white girls for sex, has been named after being found guilty of 30 separate child rape charges. Shabir Ahmed, 59, led a child sex exploitation ring of nine men who targeted vulnerable young girls in the Rochdale and Oldham areas of Greater Manchester.
Rochdale Paedophile Ringleader Named
The ringleader of a paedophile gang in Rochdale, who groomed young white girls for sex, has been named after being found guilty of 30 separate child rape charges. Shabir Ahmed, 59, led a child sex exploitation ring of nine men who targeted vulnerable young girls in the Rochdale and Oldham areas of Greater Manchester.
01 February 2006
Date rape case judges 'can influence trial outcome'
A judge's summing-up can influence a jury's decision in date rape cases, a report has suggested. The research, conducted for the British Psychological Society, presented 168 university students with a date rape scenario, which included a summing-up statement by the judge, and asked them to decide on the guilt of the alleged rapist.
Date rape case judges 'can influence trial outcome'
A judge's summing-up can influence a jury's decision in date rape cases, a report has suggested. The research, conducted for the British Psychological Society, presented 168 university students with a date rape scenario, which included a summing-up statement by the judge, and asked them to decide on the guilt of the alleged rapist.
24 November 2005
Consent 'doubt' sees rape case collapse
A rape case collapsed when a 21-year-old student told how she had been too drunk to remember whether on not she had consented to sex with a fellow student. The female student had alleged that she had been raped in the hall of a residence in Aberystwyth University.
Consent 'doubt' sees rape case collapse
A rape case collapsed when a 21-year-old student told how she had been too drunk to remember whether on not she had consented to sex with a fellow student. The female student had alleged that she had been raped in the hall of a residence in Aberystwyth University.
11 December 2014
Govt Announce Funding For Male Rape Victim Charities
A total of £600,000 in government funding has been secured to support male victims of rape. The money, being made available under the Male Rape Support Fund, will be shared between 12 charities over two years, Victims Minister Mike Penning has announced.
Govt Announce Funding For Male Rape Victim Charities
A total of £600,000 in government funding has been secured to support male victims of rape. The money, being made available under the Male Rape Support Fund, will be shared between 12 charities over two years, Victims Minister Mike Penning has announced.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A sunny but frosty start for many. However cloud increases by midday with a few showers reaching the north coast, these mostly light but spreading inland this afternoon. Chilly. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A rather cloudy evening with scattered showers. Becoming drier through the night with some good clear spells developing and a patchy frost away from coasts. Minimum temperature 0 °C.
