Menu
22/03/2006
RAF doctor faces court martial
An RAF doctor who refuses to serve in Iraq will face a court martial.
Flight Lieutenant Malcolm Kendall-Smith, 37, faces five charges of failing to comply with a lawful order after he refused to participate in training and deployment to Basra in June 2004.
The 37-year-old officer, who holds dual British/New Zealand citizenship, had previously served two tours of duty in Iraq, but refused to return last June because he believed the war was illegal.
At a pre-trial hearing last week, Flt Lt Kendall-Smith's defence counsel Philip Sapsford QC said that the officer believed that there was no lawful reasons to enter Iraq, because it had not attacked the UK. He argued that he was then entitled to disobey the orders he was given, because he believed Iraq to be under occupation.
However, at the ruling at Aldershot Court Martial Centre, Judge Advocate Jack Bayliss said that none of the orders given to Flt Lt Kendall-Smith were unlawful. He said: "I also conclude that it is no defence to a charge of wilfully disobeying a lawful order that the defendant believed that the order was not lawful."
Flt Lt Kendall-Smith is charged with failing to comply with an order on June 1, 2005 to attend RAF Kinloss for pistol and rifle training, failing to attend a helmet fitting on June 6, 2005 and failing to attend a training course between June 12 and June 24.
He is also charged with failing to attend a deployment briefing at RAF Lyneham on June 30, 2005 and failing to comply with an order to replace a squadron leader for Operation Telic in Basra by July 12, 2005.
(KMcA)
Flight Lieutenant Malcolm Kendall-Smith, 37, faces five charges of failing to comply with a lawful order after he refused to participate in training and deployment to Basra in June 2004.
The 37-year-old officer, who holds dual British/New Zealand citizenship, had previously served two tours of duty in Iraq, but refused to return last June because he believed the war was illegal.
At a pre-trial hearing last week, Flt Lt Kendall-Smith's defence counsel Philip Sapsford QC said that the officer believed that there was no lawful reasons to enter Iraq, because it had not attacked the UK. He argued that he was then entitled to disobey the orders he was given, because he believed Iraq to be under occupation.
However, at the ruling at Aldershot Court Martial Centre, Judge Advocate Jack Bayliss said that none of the orders given to Flt Lt Kendall-Smith were unlawful. He said: "I also conclude that it is no defence to a charge of wilfully disobeying a lawful order that the defendant believed that the order was not lawful."
Flt Lt Kendall-Smith is charged with failing to comply with an order on June 1, 2005 to attend RAF Kinloss for pistol and rifle training, failing to attend a helmet fitting on June 6, 2005 and failing to attend a training course between June 12 and June 24.
He is also charged with failing to attend a deployment briefing at RAF Lyneham on June 30, 2005 and failing to comply with an order to replace a squadron leader for Operation Telic in Basra by July 12, 2005.
(KMcA)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
21 October 2015
Consultation On Schools Proposal Unveiled
The government has launched a new public consultation on proposals to speed up the transformation of failing schools and schools that are deemed to be "coasting". First proposed by Education Secretary Nicky Morgan in the Education and Adoption Bill in June, the new rule will allow the government to swiftly intervene and turn around failing schools.
Consultation On Schools Proposal Unveiled
The government has launched a new public consultation on proposals to speed up the transformation of failing schools and schools that are deemed to be "coasting". First proposed by Education Secretary Nicky Morgan in the Education and Adoption Bill in June, the new rule will allow the government to swiftly intervene and turn around failing schools.
08 April 2015
Mother Of Baby's Body Discovered In Norfolk Identified
Police investigating the discovery of baby's body in a Norfolk village nearly 30 years ago have traced the mother. The body of the new-born baby was discovered in Weasenham St Peter on the 5 June 1988, however despite enquiries at the time police had been unable to identify the parents of the infant.
Mother Of Baby's Body Discovered In Norfolk Identified
Police investigating the discovery of baby's body in a Norfolk village nearly 30 years ago have traced the mother. The body of the new-born baby was discovered in Weasenham St Peter on the 5 June 1988, however despite enquiries at the time police had been unable to identify the parents of the infant.
24 July 2014
Figures Show A Rise In Retail Sales
Sales in the retail industry increased by 3.6% compared to June 2013 according to the Office for National Statistics (ONS). The quantity bought also increased by 4.5% compare to the same time last year. In June 2014, all retail sectors showed estimated rises in the quantity bought year-on-year.
Figures Show A Rise In Retail Sales
Sales in the retail industry increased by 3.6% compared to June 2013 according to the Office for National Statistics (ONS). The quantity bought also increased by 4.5% compare to the same time last year. In June 2014, all retail sectors showed estimated rises in the quantity bought year-on-year.
09 February 2011
Pair Jailed For Smash And Grab
Two men have been jailed at Southwark Crown Court for a 'smash and grab' robbery at a jewellers in Kilburn Lane, west London. Jake Maunders, 20, of Tollbridge Close and Alex Rogers, 20 of Sutton Way, pleaded guilty to the robbery at Ishtar Jewellers in Kilburn Lane.
Pair Jailed For Smash And Grab
Two men have been jailed at Southwark Crown Court for a 'smash and grab' robbery at a jewellers in Kilburn Lane, west London. Jake Maunders, 20, of Tollbridge Close and Alex Rogers, 20 of Sutton Way, pleaded guilty to the robbery at Ishtar Jewellers in Kilburn Lane.
13 April 2006
RAF doctor guilty of disobeying orders
An RAF doctor who refused to return to Iraq has been found guilty of disobeying orders at a court martial. Flight Lieutenant Dr Malcolm Kendall-Smith, 37, who was based at RAF Kinloss in Scotland, was convicted by a panel of five RAF officers of five charges of failing to comply with lawful orders at the court martial in Aldershot.
RAF doctor guilty of disobeying orders
An RAF doctor who refused to return to Iraq has been found guilty of disobeying orders at a court martial. Flight Lieutenant Dr Malcolm Kendall-Smith, 37, who was based at RAF Kinloss in Scotland, was convicted by a panel of five RAF officers of five charges of failing to comply with lawful orders at the court martial in Aldershot.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:After a dry start this morning rain will spread from the northwest across all parts. This afternoon will be dull with some patchy rain and drizzle. Becoming much milder through the afternoon. Maximum temperature 11 °C.Tonight:A cloudy evening and night with a little light rain or drizzle, perhaps some clear periods developing along the east coast. A very mild night everywhere. Minimum temperature 10 °C.
