Menu
17/01/2006
ID cards scheme sees defeat in House of Lords
The government has stated that it will be proceeding with its plans for ID cards, despite the proposal receiving a defeat on three separate counts in the House of Lords last night.
The latest blow to the scheme came when peers voted to block it on the basis that the full costs of introducing the cards was not yet known. The Lords also voted for a more secure method of registering personal data, and for greater controls regarding access to any information stored as part of the scheme.
This latest blow comes after a report from the London School of Economics (LSE) stated that the Home Office has underestimated the true costs of introducing the cards. Ministers speaking last night for the government said costs could not be detailed at this stage as this would hamper getting a good deal at the tenders stage, but numerous peers complained that such reluctance to disclose the true amount was ‘unconstitutional’.
Home Office estimates have pegged the scheme’s annual running costs at around £584m, with a combined identity card and biometric passport costing £93. However, the LSE claims that the costs could weigh in at between £10b and £19b over 10 years, if the proposals, as they stand, are put in place.
Ian Angell, Head of the LSE Department of Information Systems, said: “Contradictions, guesswork and wishful thinking on the part of the Home Office make a mockery of any pretence that this scheme is based on serious reasoning.”
The government will seek to overcome the defeat when the Bill returns to the Commons later this year.
(CL/GB)
The latest blow to the scheme came when peers voted to block it on the basis that the full costs of introducing the cards was not yet known. The Lords also voted for a more secure method of registering personal data, and for greater controls regarding access to any information stored as part of the scheme.
This latest blow comes after a report from the London School of Economics (LSE) stated that the Home Office has underestimated the true costs of introducing the cards. Ministers speaking last night for the government said costs could not be detailed at this stage as this would hamper getting a good deal at the tenders stage, but numerous peers complained that such reluctance to disclose the true amount was ‘unconstitutional’.
Home Office estimates have pegged the scheme’s annual running costs at around £584m, with a combined identity card and biometric passport costing £93. However, the LSE claims that the costs could weigh in at between £10b and £19b over 10 years, if the proposals, as they stand, are put in place.
Ian Angell, Head of the LSE Department of Information Systems, said: “Contradictions, guesswork and wishful thinking on the part of the Home Office make a mockery of any pretence that this scheme is based on serious reasoning.”
The government will seek to overcome the defeat when the Bill returns to the Commons later this year.
(CL/GB)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
28 June 2005
ID cards bill returns to the Commons
MPs are due to vote later today on the government’s controversial plans to introduce identity cards. A small number of Labour MPs are expected to vote against the scheme, which is already opposed by both the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats.
ID cards bill returns to the Commons
MPs are due to vote later today on the government’s controversial plans to introduce identity cards. A small number of Labour MPs are expected to vote against the scheme, which is already opposed by both the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats.
20 March 2012
Government Credit Cards Being Abused
An examination of transaction carried on government credit cards has uncovered evidence of unauthorised transactions. The National Audit Office report released today will show that government-issued procurement cards are being abused due to a failure to oversee their spending.
Government Credit Cards Being Abused
An examination of transaction carried on government credit cards has uncovered evidence of unauthorised transactions. The National Audit Office report released today will show that government-issued procurement cards are being abused due to a failure to oversee their spending.
26 March 2009
Minister Facing Accommodation Expenses Probe
A Government watchdog is to look into the expenses paid to the Employment Minister, Tony McNulty for his housing arrangements, it has been revealed. The Parliamentary Commission for Standards said it would investigate claims that he had received around £60,000 to cover the cost of staying at his own parents' home.
Minister Facing Accommodation Expenses Probe
A Government watchdog is to look into the expenses paid to the Employment Minister, Tony McNulty for his housing arrangements, it has been revealed. The Parliamentary Commission for Standards said it would investigate claims that he had received around £60,000 to cover the cost of staying at his own parents' home.
13 September 2012
Funeral Costs Rise For Ninth Consecutive Year
Rising for the ninth consecutive year a new survey has revealed that funeral costs have increases by 71% since 2004.
Funeral Costs Rise For Ninth Consecutive Year
Rising for the ninth consecutive year a new survey has revealed that funeral costs have increases by 71% since 2004.
06 November 2006
Blair - ID cards are 'essential'
ID cards are "essential" in order to tackle the problems of the modern world, Prime Minister Tony Blair has announced. The Prime Minister wrote an article on the subject for the 'Daily Telegraph' and also addressed the topic in his monthly press conference on Monday.
Blair - ID cards are 'essential'
ID cards are "essential" in order to tackle the problems of the modern world, Prime Minister Tony Blair has announced. The Prime Minister wrote an article on the subject for the 'Daily Telegraph' and also addressed the topic in his monthly press conference on Monday.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherThis Evening and Tonight:Showers, scattered in the evening, will clear by midnight leaving the night dry with clear spells. Perhaps a touch of ground frost. Cloud will spread east towards morning. Minimum temperature 2 °C.
