Menu
06/10/2005
Ban on prisoner votes ‘breaches human rights’
A British law, which prevents prisoners from voting, could change, after the European Court of Human Rights ruled that it was in breach of human rights.
More than 70,000 prisoners in Britain could be given the right to vote, if the current law was to change.
The case was brought by former prisoner John Hirst, who was imprisoned for manslaughter, after killing his landlady in 1980. Under the 1983 Representation of the People Act, Mr Hirst was banned from voting.
He took his case to the High Court, while still serving his sentence at Rye Hill prison in Warwickshire, arguing that the Act was in violation of the European Convention on Human Rights. He lost the case, but appealed to a seven-judge chamber of the Human Rights Court in Strasbourg, which backed him and awarded him £8,000 in costs and expenses.
The government appealed against the ruling, but the full 17-judge Grand Chamber of the court upheld it on Wednesday.
Commenting on the judgement, Mr Hirst, who was released from prison last year, said: “The human rights court has agreed with me that the government’s position is wrong – it doesn’t matter how heinous the crime, everyone is entitled to have the basic human right to vote.”
A spokesperson for the Department for Constitutional Affairs said that it would give “urgent consideration” to the Strasbourg court’s ruling and would bring forward proposals “in due course”.
The Prison Reform Trust has welcomed the decision. Director Juliet Lyon said: “This judgement confirms that people are sent to prison to lose their liberty, not their identity or their citizenship.”
However, the ruling has been criticised by the Conservatives. Shadow Attorney General Dominic Grieve said: “Giving prisoners the vote would be ludicrous. If convicted rapists and murderers are given the vote, it will bring the law into disrepute and many people will see it as making a mockery of justice.”
(KMcA/GB)
More than 70,000 prisoners in Britain could be given the right to vote, if the current law was to change.
The case was brought by former prisoner John Hirst, who was imprisoned for manslaughter, after killing his landlady in 1980. Under the 1983 Representation of the People Act, Mr Hirst was banned from voting.
He took his case to the High Court, while still serving his sentence at Rye Hill prison in Warwickshire, arguing that the Act was in violation of the European Convention on Human Rights. He lost the case, but appealed to a seven-judge chamber of the Human Rights Court in Strasbourg, which backed him and awarded him £8,000 in costs and expenses.
The government appealed against the ruling, but the full 17-judge Grand Chamber of the court upheld it on Wednesday.
Commenting on the judgement, Mr Hirst, who was released from prison last year, said: “The human rights court has agreed with me that the government’s position is wrong – it doesn’t matter how heinous the crime, everyone is entitled to have the basic human right to vote.”
A spokesperson for the Department for Constitutional Affairs said that it would give “urgent consideration” to the Strasbourg court’s ruling and would bring forward proposals “in due course”.
The Prison Reform Trust has welcomed the decision. Director Juliet Lyon said: “This judgement confirms that people are sent to prison to lose their liberty, not their identity or their citizenship.”
However, the ruling has been criticised by the Conservatives. Shadow Attorney General Dominic Grieve said: “Giving prisoners the vote would be ludicrous. If convicted rapists and murderers are given the vote, it will bring the law into disrepute and many people will see it as making a mockery of justice.”
(KMcA/GB)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
24 March 2005
Ethiopian army branded ‘murderers and rapists’
The Ethiopian military has committed widespread murder, rape and torture against the Anuak population since December 2003, Human Rights Watch (HRW) said in a report released today.
Ethiopian army branded ‘murderers and rapists’
The Ethiopian military has committed widespread murder, rape and torture against the Anuak population since December 2003, Human Rights Watch (HRW) said in a report released today.
23 November 2011
Quality Of Elderly Care Breaching Human Rights
An inquiry into the treatment of the elderly by the 'home care' system has found the quality of care was in breach of human rights.
Quality Of Elderly Care Breaching Human Rights
An inquiry into the treatment of the elderly by the 'home care' system has found the quality of care was in breach of human rights.
01 October 2015
New Consumer Rights Act For Digital Content Introduced
A new Consumer Rights Act has been introduced covering digital content, giving customers downloading music or buying ebooks new legal rights. The new Act has been created as shoppers increasingly spend money on digital content, with more than £2.8 billion spent on downloaded music, video and games in 2014, up 18% from the previous year.
New Consumer Rights Act For Digital Content Introduced
A new Consumer Rights Act has been introduced covering digital content, giving customers downloading music or buying ebooks new legal rights. The new Act has been created as shoppers increasingly spend money on digital content, with more than £2.8 billion spent on downloaded music, video and games in 2014, up 18% from the previous year.
02 November 2010
Prisoners May Get Right To Vote
Thousands of UK prisoners may get the right to vote after the Government conceded defeat in a long-running battle with the European Court of Human Rights over the issue. According to reports, the Government has reluctantly accepted the European court's ruling that the current ban, which has been in place in the UK for 140 years, is unlawful.
Prisoners May Get Right To Vote
Thousands of UK prisoners may get the right to vote after the Government conceded defeat in a long-running battle with the European Court of Human Rights over the issue. According to reports, the Government has reluctantly accepted the European court's ruling that the current ban, which has been in place in the UK for 140 years, is unlawful.
24 September 2013
Former Prisoner Challenges Police Collection Of DNA Samples
A police force is awaiting a judge's ruling over whether their collection of DNA samples from thousands of former prisoners is lawful, or should be destroyed. It is understood that the force, which cannot be named for legal reasons, was collecting DNA samples from former prisoners, convicted of serious crimes as part of Operation Nutmeg.
Former Prisoner Challenges Police Collection Of DNA Samples
A police force is awaiting a judge's ruling over whether their collection of DNA samples from thousands of former prisoners is lawful, or should be destroyed. It is understood that the force, which cannot be named for legal reasons, was collecting DNA samples from former prisoners, convicted of serious crimes as part of Operation Nutmeg.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:A sunny but frosty start for many. However cloud increases by midday with a few showers reaching the north coast, these mostly light but spreading inland this afternoon. Chilly. Maximum temperature 8 °C.Tonight:A rather cloudy evening with scattered showers. Becoming drier through the night with some good clear spells developing and a patchy frost away from coasts. Minimum temperature 0 °C.
