Menu
21/07/2005
Convictions quashed in 'shaken baby' cases
Two convictions in so-called "shaken baby" cases have been quashed and in a third case the sentence has been reduced on appeal.
A conviction for manslaughter against 36-year-old Lorraine Harris from Long Eaton in Derbyshire was quashed. A conviction for grievous bodily harm against 34-year-olf Michael Faulder of Gateshead was also quashed at the Court of Appeal.
In the third case, that of Raymond Rock of Great Yarmouth in Norfolk, a murder conviction was reduced to manslaughter with a sentence of seven years. Rock has already served six years and would be eligible for release.
A fourth appeal, concerning a manslaughter conviction in regard to Alan Cherry, was dismissed.
The convictions hinged on expert medical evidence and the three Judges on the review panel directed that the presence of the trio of symptoms held to be typical of "shaken baby syndrome" did not automatically imply that a crime had committed.
The three symptoms, swelling of the brain, bleeding around the brain and skull and bleeding in the retina, had been put forward as typical of "shaken baby syndrome." The jury in each of the case had been asked to infer that these symptoms had been as a result of violent handling. However following the successful appeal earlier this year by Angela Cannings against a conviction for the murder of her two sons, the Attorney General had ordered a review of the four cases.
The appeal review has potential implications for around 90 other similar cases.
(SP/GB)
A conviction for manslaughter against 36-year-old Lorraine Harris from Long Eaton in Derbyshire was quashed. A conviction for grievous bodily harm against 34-year-olf Michael Faulder of Gateshead was also quashed at the Court of Appeal.
In the third case, that of Raymond Rock of Great Yarmouth in Norfolk, a murder conviction was reduced to manslaughter with a sentence of seven years. Rock has already served six years and would be eligible for release.
A fourth appeal, concerning a manslaughter conviction in regard to Alan Cherry, was dismissed.
The convictions hinged on expert medical evidence and the three Judges on the review panel directed that the presence of the trio of symptoms held to be typical of "shaken baby syndrome" did not automatically imply that a crime had committed.
The three symptoms, swelling of the brain, bleeding around the brain and skull and bleeding in the retina, had been put forward as typical of "shaken baby syndrome." The jury in each of the case had been asked to infer that these symptoms had been as a result of violent handling. However following the successful appeal earlier this year by Angela Cannings against a conviction for the murder of her two sons, the Attorney General had ordered a review of the four cases.
The appeal review has potential implications for around 90 other similar cases.
(SP/GB)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
14 December 2007
Barry George Denies Jill Dando Murder
Barry George has pleaded not guilty to the murder of BBC TV presenter Jill Dando, during a hearing at the Old Bailey on Friday morning. The 47-year-old was sentenced to life imprisonment in 2001 for the murder of Miss Dando, who was shot dead outside her house in Fulham, west London, in April 1999.
Barry George Denies Jill Dando Murder
Barry George has pleaded not guilty to the murder of BBC TV presenter Jill Dando, during a hearing at the Old Bailey on Friday morning. The 47-year-old was sentenced to life imprisonment in 2001 for the murder of Miss Dando, who was shot dead outside her house in Fulham, west London, in April 1999.
23 July 2003
Millionaire tycoon has manslaughter conviction quashed
Millionaire businessman Nicholas van Hoogstraten, who was jailed for the manslaughter of a business associate, has had his conviction quashed and a retrial ordered at the Court of Appeal today. The property tycoon will remain in custody and face a manslaughter charge in 28 days time. It is expected that he will be back in court within two months.
Millionaire tycoon has manslaughter conviction quashed
Millionaire businessman Nicholas van Hoogstraten, who was jailed for the manslaughter of a business associate, has had his conviction quashed and a retrial ordered at the Court of Appeal today. The property tycoon will remain in custody and face a manslaughter charge in 28 days time. It is expected that he will be back in court within two months.
08 December 2003
Ruth Ellis' murder conviction upheld
The murder conviction of the last woman to be hanged in Britain, Ruth Ellis, has been upheld today at the Court of Appeal. The appeal was dismissed after judges ruled that no new evidence had been presented and the appeal was consequently "without merit".
Ruth Ellis' murder conviction upheld
The murder conviction of the last woman to be hanged in Britain, Ruth Ellis, has been upheld today at the Court of Appeal. The appeal was dismissed after judges ruled that no new evidence had been presented and the appeal was consequently "without merit".
18 March 2009
Hodgson Conviction Quashed After 27 Years
A man who has spent 27 years in prison has had his conviction quashed at the Court of Appeal. Sean Hodgson, now 57, was sentenced to life imprisonment for strangling 22-year-old gas board clerk and part-time barmaid Teresa De Simone in Southampton.
Hodgson Conviction Quashed After 27 Years
A man who has spent 27 years in prison has had his conviction quashed at the Court of Appeal. Sean Hodgson, now 57, was sentenced to life imprisonment for strangling 22-year-old gas board clerk and part-time barmaid Teresa De Simone in Southampton.
20 June 2007
Kenneth Noye to seek appeal against conviction
Convicted murderer Kenneth Noye is going to the High Court in an attempt to get his life sentence overturned. Noye, 60, was jailed for life in 2000 for the murder of Stephen Cameron on the M25 at Swanley in Kent in 1996.
Kenneth Noye to seek appeal against conviction
Convicted murderer Kenneth Noye is going to the High Court in an attempt to get his life sentence overturned. Noye, 60, was jailed for life in 2000 for the murder of Stephen Cameron on the M25 at Swanley in Kent in 1996.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherThis Evening and Tonight:Showers, scattered in the evening, will clear by midnight leaving the night dry with clear spells. Perhaps a touch of ground frost. Cloud will spread east towards morning. Minimum temperature 2 °C.
