Menu
21/04/2005
Parents of baby Charlotte lose legal bid
The parents of baby Charlotte Wyatt have lost their latest legal bid to overturn a decision allowing doctors to let her die if she stops breathing.
At a hearing at the High Court, Mr Justice Hedley upheld last October’s ruling that staff at St Mary’s hospital in Portsmouth should not resuscitate Charlotte if she stopped breathing.
Charlotte, who is now eighteen-months-old, was born three months premature in October 2003. She was just 5 inches long and weighted only 1lb when she was born suffering from serious brain, lung and kidney damage.
At last October’s High Court hearing, doctors from St Mary’s argued that Charlotte’s condition had become so bad that she had “no feeling other than continuing pain”. It would be “pointless and possibly inhumane”, doctors argued, to resuscitate Charlotte if she stopped breathing because it would only prolong the child’s suffering.
However, Charlotte’s parents, Darren and Debbie Wyatt, insist that her condition is improving and they presented the court with independent medical evidence stating that Charlotte was not in constant pain and was now alert and responsive to stimuli, including movement and sound. Charlotte remains seriously ill, however, and lives almost constantly in an oxygen box.
Mr Justice Hedley said that it “would not be in Charlotte’s best interests to die in the course of futile aggressive treatment”. He said that all treatment up to, but not including intubation and ventilation, would be in Charlotte’s best interests, if she should stop breathing, “but nothing further”.
(KMcA/GB)
At a hearing at the High Court, Mr Justice Hedley upheld last October’s ruling that staff at St Mary’s hospital in Portsmouth should not resuscitate Charlotte if she stopped breathing.
Charlotte, who is now eighteen-months-old, was born three months premature in October 2003. She was just 5 inches long and weighted only 1lb when she was born suffering from serious brain, lung and kidney damage.
At last October’s High Court hearing, doctors from St Mary’s argued that Charlotte’s condition had become so bad that she had “no feeling other than continuing pain”. It would be “pointless and possibly inhumane”, doctors argued, to resuscitate Charlotte if she stopped breathing because it would only prolong the child’s suffering.
However, Charlotte’s parents, Darren and Debbie Wyatt, insist that her condition is improving and they presented the court with independent medical evidence stating that Charlotte was not in constant pain and was now alert and responsive to stimuli, including movement and sound. Charlotte remains seriously ill, however, and lives almost constantly in an oxygen box.
Mr Justice Hedley said that it “would not be in Charlotte’s best interests to die in the course of futile aggressive treatment”. He said that all treatment up to, but not including intubation and ventilation, would be in Charlotte’s best interests, if she should stop breathing, “but nothing further”.
(KMcA/GB)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
21 October 2005
Baby Charlotte ruling lifted
The parents of severely brain-damaged baby, Charlotte Wyatt, have won the right for her to be resuscitated if she falls ill. Mr Justice Hedley reversed the previous decision, which allowed doctors not to resuscitate Charlotte if she stopped breathing, at the High Court on Friday. The decision coincides with Charlotte’s second birthday.
Baby Charlotte ruling lifted
The parents of severely brain-damaged baby, Charlotte Wyatt, have won the right for her to be resuscitated if she falls ill. Mr Justice Hedley reversed the previous decision, which allowed doctors not to resuscitate Charlotte if she stopped breathing, at the High Court on Friday. The decision coincides with Charlotte’s second birthday.
25 March 2015
Police Must Record Vehicle Stops - HMIC
Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabulary (HMIC) has called on police forces in England and Wales to record all traffic stops. The HMIC said that it was was concerned that black and minority ethnic drivers are being disproportionately stopped by police.
Police Must Record Vehicle Stops - HMIC
Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabulary (HMIC) has called on police forces in England and Wales to record all traffic stops. The HMIC said that it was was concerned that black and minority ethnic drivers are being disproportionately stopped by police.
04 December 2014
Body Found Is Missing Mother Charlotte Bevan
A body found in the search for a missing mother and her baby has been officially identified as Charlotte Bevan. Ms Bevan's body was discovered at the Avon Gorge on Wednesday. Ms Bevan went missing from Bristol's St Michael's Hospital on Tuesday with her four-day-old baby daughter.
Body Found Is Missing Mother Charlotte Bevan
A body found in the search for a missing mother and her baby has been officially identified as Charlotte Bevan. Ms Bevan's body was discovered at the Avon Gorge on Wednesday. Ms Bevan went missing from Bristol's St Michael's Hospital on Tuesday with her four-day-old baby daughter.
01 March 2007
Charlotte Church confirms pregnancy
Singer and television presenter Charlotte Church has announced that she is pregnant. The 21-year-old is expecting her first child with her rugby star boyfriend Gavin Henson. The news was confirmed in a statement from the star's management on her web-site.
Charlotte Church confirms pregnancy
Singer and television presenter Charlotte Church has announced that she is pregnant. The 21-year-old is expecting her first child with her rugby star boyfriend Gavin Henson. The news was confirmed in a statement from the star's management on her web-site.
16 October 2006
Search on for foster home for baby Charlotte
A severely disabled child who has been at the centre of a legal battle over her right to live, could be fostered, following the separation of her parents. Charlotte Wyatt was born three months prematurely, weighing just 1lb, and suffers serious brain, lung and kidney damage.
Search on for foster home for baby Charlotte
A severely disabled child who has been at the centre of a legal battle over her right to live, could be fostered, following the separation of her parents. Charlotte Wyatt was born three months prematurely, weighing just 1lb, and suffers serious brain, lung and kidney damage.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:It will be cloudy again throughout the day. Mainly dry in the morning, but patchy drizzle in places, becoming more widespread and persistent in the afternoon. Freshening southwesterly winds. Maximum temperature 12 °C.Tonight:Cloudy with a spell of heavy rain pushing south through late evening and the early hours, followed by some clear spells. Minimum temperature 6 °C.
