Menu
16/05/2003
Passive smoking report sparks row
Health experts are fuming today after the British Medical Journal (BMJ) carried a report which flies in the face of received wisdom that passive smoking causes deaths from heart disease and lung cancer.
Researchers - James Enstrom of the University of California and Geoffrey Kabat of New Rochelle in New York – collected data from 118,094 people who enrolled in the American Cancer Society cancer prevention study in late 1959 and who were followed by researchers until 1998. The study took particular focus on the 35,561 non-smokers who had a spouse in the study with known smoking habits.
The study found that "no significant associations" were found for current or former exposure to environmental tobacco smoke with later disease.
According to the study: "The results do not support a causal relation between environmental tobacco smoke and tobacco related mortality, although they do not rule out a small effect. The association between exposure to environmental tobacco smoke and coronary heart disease and lung cancer may be considerably weaker than generally believed."
The findings have sparked a backlash among anti-smoking groups, environmental health lobbiests and government figures.
A BMJ editorial which ran in the same issue suggested the authors “may have over-emphasised the negative nature of their findings”.
Amanda Sandford, Research Manager of the anti-tobacco campaigning group ASH, said: “The tobacco industry has been desperately tying to disprove the harmful consequences of passive smoking for years. This paper is just the latest in a long campaign to sow the seeds of doubt about the dangers of breathing in environmental tobacco smoke.
"The authors appear to be deliberately downplaying the findings to suit their tobacco paymasters.”
ASH also expressed concern that the British Medical Journal had published such a biased piece of research. Ms Sandford added: “Questions will inevitably be asked about the decision to publish research conducted by scientists in the pay of the tobacco industry.
"This could be very damaging as it will be used by industry lobbyists to argue against laws to ban smoking in public places and workplaces. We would urge policy makers not to be swayed by this study but to respect the reputable science that has already shown passive smoking to be a killer.”
Dr Ian Campbell, President of the British Thoracic Society (BTS) - the UK's professional body of respiratory specialists - commenting in response to research on the effects of passive smoking, published in this week's BMJ said: "This is yet another piece of evidence in the difficult debate on the effects of passive smoking.
"We believe that passive smoking has a much weaker effect on the lungs than actual smoking, but there are real risks involved, which need to be addressed.
"Medical evidence has conclusively shown that passive smoking has a detrimental effect on children’s lungs and there is also good evidence that suggests that passive smoking worsens the effects of asthma.
"Further research into the effects of passive smoking on lung health are needed and should be encouraged by governmental and other funding agencies."
(GMcG)
Researchers - James Enstrom of the University of California and Geoffrey Kabat of New Rochelle in New York – collected data from 118,094 people who enrolled in the American Cancer Society cancer prevention study in late 1959 and who were followed by researchers until 1998. The study took particular focus on the 35,561 non-smokers who had a spouse in the study with known smoking habits.
The study found that "no significant associations" were found for current or former exposure to environmental tobacco smoke with later disease.
According to the study: "The results do not support a causal relation between environmental tobacco smoke and tobacco related mortality, although they do not rule out a small effect. The association between exposure to environmental tobacco smoke and coronary heart disease and lung cancer may be considerably weaker than generally believed."
The findings have sparked a backlash among anti-smoking groups, environmental health lobbiests and government figures.
A BMJ editorial which ran in the same issue suggested the authors “may have over-emphasised the negative nature of their findings”.
Amanda Sandford, Research Manager of the anti-tobacco campaigning group ASH, said: “The tobacco industry has been desperately tying to disprove the harmful consequences of passive smoking for years. This paper is just the latest in a long campaign to sow the seeds of doubt about the dangers of breathing in environmental tobacco smoke.
"The authors appear to be deliberately downplaying the findings to suit their tobacco paymasters.”
ASH also expressed concern that the British Medical Journal had published such a biased piece of research. Ms Sandford added: “Questions will inevitably be asked about the decision to publish research conducted by scientists in the pay of the tobacco industry.
"This could be very damaging as it will be used by industry lobbyists to argue against laws to ban smoking in public places and workplaces. We would urge policy makers not to be swayed by this study but to respect the reputable science that has already shown passive smoking to be a killer.”
Dr Ian Campbell, President of the British Thoracic Society (BTS) - the UK's professional body of respiratory specialists - commenting in response to research on the effects of passive smoking, published in this week's BMJ said: "This is yet another piece of evidence in the difficult debate on the effects of passive smoking.
"We believe that passive smoking has a much weaker effect on the lungs than actual smoking, but there are real risks involved, which need to be addressed.
"Medical evidence has conclusively shown that passive smoking has a detrimental effect on children’s lungs and there is also good evidence that suggests that passive smoking worsens the effects of asthma.
"Further research into the effects of passive smoking on lung health are needed and should be encouraged by governmental and other funding agencies."
(GMcG)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
28 January 2005
Increased cancer risk for smokers' children
A study has revealed a possible increased risk of lung cancer, for children exposed to passive smoking.
Increased cancer risk for smokers' children
A study has revealed a possible increased risk of lung cancer, for children exposed to passive smoking.
04 March 2011
Smoking Increases Risk Of Breast Cancer In Postmenopausal Women
Ahead of No Smoking Day on March 9th, bmj.com has published research indicating that postmenopausal women who smoke, or used to smoke, have up to a 16% higher risk of developing breast cancer compared to women who have never smoked.
Smoking Increases Risk Of Breast Cancer In Postmenopausal Women
Ahead of No Smoking Day on March 9th, bmj.com has published research indicating that postmenopausal women who smoke, or used to smoke, have up to a 16% higher risk of developing breast cancer compared to women who have never smoked.
22 June 2005
Survey calls for smoking ban in family homes
Nearly three-quarters of people believe that smoking should be banned in households with children, according to research by Developing Patient Partnerships (DPP). The survey of 1275 adults, conducted by ICM Research, found that 72% of people questioned were in favour of a ban, including 65% of smokers.
Survey calls for smoking ban in family homes
Nearly three-quarters of people believe that smoking should be banned in households with children, according to research by Developing Patient Partnerships (DPP). The survey of 1275 adults, conducted by ICM Research, found that 72% of people questioned were in favour of a ban, including 65% of smokers.
08 April 2003
Report reveals passive smoking kills three people a day
New research has revealed that three people each day die due to passive smoking at work and has prompted renewed calls for laws to ban smoking in workplaces. According to research in ‘A Killer on the Loose’ published today, on the eve of a major conference on workplace smoking, every year 1,200 people in the UK die as a result of passive smoking.
Report reveals passive smoking kills three people a day
New research has revealed that three people each day die due to passive smoking at work and has prompted renewed calls for laws to ban smoking in workplaces. According to research in ‘A Killer on the Loose’ published today, on the eve of a major conference on workplace smoking, every year 1,200 people in the UK die as a result of passive smoking.
28 April 2005
BMA reinforces call for UK-wide smoking ban
The British Medical Association (BMA) has reinforced its call for a UK-wide ban on smoking in public places, with the publication of a report which, it claims, will “counter the myths” generated by opponents to the ban.
BMA reinforces call for UK-wide smoking ban
The British Medical Association (BMA) has reinforced its call for a UK-wide ban on smoking in public places, with the publication of a report which, it claims, will “counter the myths” generated by opponents to the ban.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:It will be cloudy again throughout the day. Mainly dry in the morning, but patchy drizzle in places, becoming more widespread and persistent in the afternoon. Freshening southwesterly winds. Maximum temperature 12 °C.Tonight:Cloudy with a spell of heavy rain pushing south through late evening and the early hours, followed by some clear spells. Minimum temperature 6 °C.
