19/10/2010
NHS Reforms Could Mean More Patients Seeking Treatment Abroad
The planned shake-up of the NHS in England could see a rise in the number of patients seeking treatment elsewhere in the European Union, warned experts on bmj.com today.
Researchers at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine and the Royal College of Nursing say more people could turn elsewhere if they face long waits for treatment or other forms of rationing as new GP commissioning groups seek to control their budgets.
They argue this is “another challenge for general practice commissioning” and look at the implications for healthcare planning across Europe.
British residents have had the right to obtain treatment in another EU countries since 1971, although currently the number is small, writes Helena Legido-Quigley and colleagues.
Initially, the opportunities were limited but, since 1998, a series of court rulings have increased patients’ rights to treatment in other EU member states, particularly for non-hospital care.
However, there is still a lack of clarity about whether patients can go abroad freely, without seeking authorisation, to use specialist medical equipment or expensive facilities usually located in hospitals.
A recent case ruled it was necessary that European law “did not threaten a system of planning that would ensure an appropriate geographical distribution of such costly equipment.”
This ruling is important, say the authors, because it begins to clarify the previously uncertain legal interface between hospital and non-hospital care. They write: “It is not whether complex treatments must or must not be provided in a hospital setting. Rather, it is whether their cost and the importance of avoiding waste from the underuse of facilities demands that their distribution be subject to planning.”
This also supports the English Department of Health’s advice, issued earlier this year, which highlighted the lack of clarity about use of specialised or cost intensive equipment or infrastructure. If general practice commissioning groups do come about they may not have to deal with many patients who choose to obtain treatment abroad, but they should be aware that some may exercise their rights to do so, say the authors. Where this involves inpatient care or “major medical equipment” they will need to establish appropriate mechanisms for authorisation. How they will do this remains to be seen.
(BMcN)
Researchers at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine and the Royal College of Nursing say more people could turn elsewhere if they face long waits for treatment or other forms of rationing as new GP commissioning groups seek to control their budgets.
They argue this is “another challenge for general practice commissioning” and look at the implications for healthcare planning across Europe.
British residents have had the right to obtain treatment in another EU countries since 1971, although currently the number is small, writes Helena Legido-Quigley and colleagues.
Initially, the opportunities were limited but, since 1998, a series of court rulings have increased patients’ rights to treatment in other EU member states, particularly for non-hospital care.
However, there is still a lack of clarity about whether patients can go abroad freely, without seeking authorisation, to use specialist medical equipment or expensive facilities usually located in hospitals.
A recent case ruled it was necessary that European law “did not threaten a system of planning that would ensure an appropriate geographical distribution of such costly equipment.”
This ruling is important, say the authors, because it begins to clarify the previously uncertain legal interface between hospital and non-hospital care. They write: “It is not whether complex treatments must or must not be provided in a hospital setting. Rather, it is whether their cost and the importance of avoiding waste from the underuse of facilities demands that their distribution be subject to planning.”
This also supports the English Department of Health’s advice, issued earlier this year, which highlighted the lack of clarity about use of specialised or cost intensive equipment or infrastructure. If general practice commissioning groups do come about they may not have to deal with many patients who choose to obtain treatment abroad, but they should be aware that some may exercise their rights to do so, say the authors. Where this involves inpatient care or “major medical equipment” they will need to establish appropriate mechanisms for authorisation. How they will do this remains to be seen.
(BMcN)
Related UK National News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
06 July 2005
Patients prefer better care to faster treatment, report claims
Patients would prefer to wait for better hospital treatment, rather than go to a hospital with shorter waiting lists. A study, conducted by RAND Europe, the King’s Fund and City University, found that patients were more likely to choose to be treated at a hospital with a good reputation rather than one that has shorter waiting times.
Patients prefer better care to faster treatment, report claims
Patients would prefer to wait for better hospital treatment, rather than go to a hospital with shorter waiting lists. A study, conducted by RAND Europe, the King’s Fund and City University, found that patients were more likely to choose to be treated at a hospital with a good reputation rather than one that has shorter waiting times.
22 September 2008
Scottish Government Pledges Cap On Surgery Waiting Times
Scottish patients may soon have a legal guarantee that they will wait no longer than 12 weeks for surgery. The Scottish Government's Patient Rights Bill proposes a strict limit on how long they have to wait from their surgical referral to receiving their operation.
Scottish Government Pledges Cap On Surgery Waiting Times
Scottish patients may soon have a legal guarantee that they will wait no longer than 12 weeks for surgery. The Scottish Government's Patient Rights Bill proposes a strict limit on how long they have to wait from their surgical referral to receiving their operation.
05 November 2008
NHS Drug 'Top Up' Plans Announced
Patients will be able to pay for medicines privately, as well as receiving National Health Service (NHS) treatment, under new plans drawn up by ministers. Health Secretary Alan Johnson made the announcement yesterday that patients, who pay extra for 'top up' drugs, will no longer lose their right to receive NHS care.
NHS Drug 'Top Up' Plans Announced
Patients will be able to pay for medicines privately, as well as receiving National Health Service (NHS) treatment, under new plans drawn up by ministers. Health Secretary Alan Johnson made the announcement yesterday that patients, who pay extra for 'top up' drugs, will no longer lose their right to receive NHS care.
04 August 2004
NHS patients not consulted enough during treatment, says survey
Many NHS patients are not involved enough in decisions about their care and so cannot give meaningful consent to treatment, according to the Healthcare Commission. Over 300,000 patients were asked about their experiences in 568 English NHS trusts for five commission the surveys published today.
NHS patients not consulted enough during treatment, says survey
Many NHS patients are not involved enough in decisions about their care and so cannot give meaningful consent to treatment, according to the Healthcare Commission. Over 300,000 patients were asked about their experiences in 568 English NHS trusts for five commission the surveys published today.
23 March 2004
NHS coped well with pressures of winter: watchdog
The NHS coped well with the traditional winter demand and patients received a better service than the NHS has previously been able to provide, the public service's watchdog said today. This was the finding of an assessment by the Emergency Care Tsar, Sir George Alberti, which was today presented to the Health Secretary John Reid.
NHS coped well with pressures of winter: watchdog
The NHS coped well with the traditional winter demand and patients received a better service than the NHS has previously been able to provide, the public service's watchdog said today. This was the finding of an assessment by the Emergency Care Tsar, Sir George Alberti, which was today presented to the Health Secretary John Reid.