30/06/2008

Public Accounts Committee Slams 'Scam'

The NI Executive's Public Accounts Committee (PAC) has attacked the way a former employee of a 'shamed' trade body has since been appointed to public posts - despite outstanding questions over the way funding was handled.

The PAC report examined the Hospitality Association of Northern Ireland (HANI), which had been 'the voice' of the Province's hotel industry up to its financial collapse.

However, the organisation is alleged to have misappropriated taxpayers' money and ripped off the European Union, as an Assembly report released today revealed.

The report into the Hospitality Association of Northern Ireland (HANI) described the case as "scandalous".

HANI received some £860,000 in public funding between 1995 and 1998 to run training programmes.

The MLAs also said the organisation had over-claimed on an EU-backed training scheme.

"Given the nature of the shortcomings, the Committee must conclude that HANI was, in effect, 'ripping off' EU Peace and Reconciliation monies," it added.

However, police investigated the paperwork and concluded that no crime had been committed.

But one of the Province's most senior civil servants has been criticised in today's Assembly report on the Hospitality Association of Northern Ireland.

Dr Aideen McGinley, Permanent Secretary at the Department for Employment and Learning, gave evidence to the PAC earlier this year on HANI.

The committee has now castigated the Department on government oversight of the body and the public appointments of the ex-employee.

The MLAs' report also stated: "At times during the evidence session, the witnesses from DEL seemed more intent on obscuring the issues, than helping the Committee to highlight the many weaknesses involved in the case.

"This is unacceptable. The Committee expects the full co-operation of Departmental witnesses in its efforts to expose poor practice, not weak attempts to excuse behaviour and a failure to condemn behaviour that was clearly inappropriate."

The Northern Ireland Hotels Federation (NIHF) was itself facing an audit probe in 2004 by the Certification Officer, a regulator who had previously examined HANI.

However, the Federation fought a successful legal battle to establish that it was not covered by the Certification Officer's remit.

As well as fighting its protracted legal battle, the Hotels Federation has firmly denied any wrongdoing.

(BMcC)

Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.

25 August 2010
NAMA Applauded At Stormont
There has been high-level support expressed for the work of the Irish Republic's National Asset Management Agency, (NAMA) and its impact on NI finances.
29 April 2009
Education Board 'Fraud' Goes Before Assembly Committee
A NI Assembly committee is to hold discussions today about poor practices in awarding tenders for building work in Belfast Education and Library Board premises.
28 June 2002
Executive under-spend criticised by MLAs
Following reports that government departments were under-spending budgets to the tune of £1 million a day, Finance Committee members have launched a scathing attack on executive spending practices.
24 January 2007
Education funding boost for Northern Ireland
Government funding for integrated education in Northern Ireland is to increase by £25m over the next financial year, it has been announced by Education Minister Maria Eagle. This translates into a 6.3% increase in cash to reflect a 3.7% increase in pupils.
25 May 2004
'Errors' and 'failures' led to departmental overspend, says PAC
Errors in estimates and a failure to properly monitor budgets led to two Northern Ireland departments overspending by around £4.5 million, according to a report published today by the Commons Public Accounts Committee (PAC). The PAC report found that in 2002-2003, two departments incurred "resource excesses" with a total value of £4.