Menu
19/04/2013
BBC Test Uncovers 'Fish Fraud'
Tests commissioned by BBC Northern Ireland have found some food products, labelled as cod, do not contain actually contain any cod at all.
The results came following a BBC NI request to Belfast's Institute for Global Food Security to examine 30 foods.
The move was a result of the recent horsemeat scare, according to the BBC.
Two out of 10 products, labelled as cod, did not contain any traces of that fish whatsoever.
The institute said cheaper types of fish were being used instead. The institute is based at Queen's University, Belfast.
Director Professor Chris Elliott has described the findings as "fish fraud".
"People are buying cod, which is a high value fish, and actually they are getting a low value fish," he told the BBC.
He said it was "another example of the integrity of the food chain being shown to be substandard".
Last month, the BBC bought 30 food products at random from supermarkets, shops and butchers in Belfast and elsewhere in Northern Ireland and submitted them to the institute for testing.
Ten products labelled as beef were tested by QUB for traces of horsemeat. Ten processed lamb products were tested for cross-contamination with pork. All samples were found to be as described on the labelling, according to the BBC.
But Queen's then sent 10 cod products to an institute in Scotland for DNA testing.
"Only in eight of the 10 cases they could find cod being present," said Professor Elliott.
"Does it have an impact on safety? Really, it does not. People are buying cod, which is a high value fish, and actually they are getting a low value fish. The industry has to take this seriously."
The Northern Ireland Retail Consortium said any labelling issue was of concern.
Its director, Aodhán Connolly, told the BBC: "It alarms me it could be a knock for consumer confidence.
"We have a series of audits. Otherwise we would not be able to tell consumers what species they are buying, how it was caught, or even what region it is from.
"We are always confident those processes are in place. If you are saying there have been problems identified then we will step up to the plate."
(IT/H)
The results came following a BBC NI request to Belfast's Institute for Global Food Security to examine 30 foods.
The move was a result of the recent horsemeat scare, according to the BBC.
Two out of 10 products, labelled as cod, did not contain any traces of that fish whatsoever.
The institute said cheaper types of fish were being used instead. The institute is based at Queen's University, Belfast.
Director Professor Chris Elliott has described the findings as "fish fraud".
"People are buying cod, which is a high value fish, and actually they are getting a low value fish," he told the BBC.
He said it was "another example of the integrity of the food chain being shown to be substandard".
Last month, the BBC bought 30 food products at random from supermarkets, shops and butchers in Belfast and elsewhere in Northern Ireland and submitted them to the institute for testing.
Ten products labelled as beef were tested by QUB for traces of horsemeat. Ten processed lamb products were tested for cross-contamination with pork. All samples were found to be as described on the labelling, according to the BBC.
But Queen's then sent 10 cod products to an institute in Scotland for DNA testing.
"Only in eight of the 10 cases they could find cod being present," said Professor Elliott.
"Does it have an impact on safety? Really, it does not. People are buying cod, which is a high value fish, and actually they are getting a low value fish. The industry has to take this seriously."
The Northern Ireland Retail Consortium said any labelling issue was of concern.
Its director, Aodhán Connolly, told the BBC: "It alarms me it could be a knock for consumer confidence.
"We have a series of audits. Otherwise we would not be able to tell consumers what species they are buying, how it was caught, or even what region it is from.
"We are always confident those processes are in place. If you are saying there have been problems identified then we will step up to the plate."
(IT/H)
Related Northern Ireland News Stories
Click here for the latest headlines.
25 November 2010
Dumping Of Tonnes Of Fish Angers MLA
A leading politician, the Ulster Unionist Deputy Leader, John McCallister, has hit out over tonnes of fish being caught and then tipped dead back into the sea as waste.
Dumping Of Tonnes Of Fish Angers MLA
A leading politician, the Ulster Unionist Deputy Leader, John McCallister, has hit out over tonnes of fish being caught and then tipped dead back into the sea as waste.
27 June 2018
NIEA Issues Warning Over Summer Pollution
Following a major fish kill in Armagh and amid the current hot weather, the Northern Ireland Environment Agency (NIEA) have issued a pollution warning. Industry, landowners and farmers are being urged to take extra care to protect waters from pollution.
NIEA Issues Warning Over Summer Pollution
Following a major fish kill in Armagh and amid the current hot weather, the Northern Ireland Environment Agency (NIEA) have issued a pollution warning. Industry, landowners and farmers are being urged to take extra care to protect waters from pollution.
11 October 2016
Investigation Launched Following Major Fish Kill In Co Down
An investigation has been launched following a major fish kill at Carrig River in Newcastle, Co Down. The Northern Ireland Environment Agency (NIEA) is currently on site investigating the pollution incident after it was reported on Saturday, 08 October.
Investigation Launched Following Major Fish Kill In Co Down
An investigation has been launched following a major fish kill at Carrig River in Newcastle, Co Down. The Northern Ireland Environment Agency (NIEA) is currently on site investigating the pollution incident after it was reported on Saturday, 08 October.
31 October 2014
Major Fish Kill Declared In Ballyclare
A "major fish kill" has been declared in Six Mile Water, Ballyclare. On Wednesday (29 October), the Northern Ireland Environment Agency (NIEA) received a report that a number of fish had been found dead in Six Mile Water. A Water Quality Inspector for NIEA was sent to the area to investigate and determine the environmental impact of the incident.
Major Fish Kill Declared In Ballyclare
A "major fish kill" has been declared in Six Mile Water, Ballyclare. On Wednesday (29 October), the Northern Ireland Environment Agency (NIEA) received a report that a number of fish had been found dead in Six Mile Water. A Water Quality Inspector for NIEA was sent to the area to investigate and determine the environmental impact of the incident.
25 July 2014
Major Fish Kill In County Armagh
A major fish kill has been reported in County Armagh. It is believed to have been caused by pollution from farm waste, according to the Northern Ireland Environment Agency (NIEA). At least 60 fish have been reported to have been found dead in the Bessbrook River. The NIEA expect this number to rise.
Major Fish Kill In County Armagh
A major fish kill has been reported in County Armagh. It is believed to have been caused by pollution from farm waste, according to the Northern Ireland Environment Agency (NIEA). At least 60 fish have been reported to have been found dead in the Bessbrook River. The NIEA expect this number to rise.
-
Northern Ireland WeatherToday:It will be cloudy again throughout the day. Mainly dry in the morning, but patchy drizzle in places, becoming more widespread and persistent in the afternoon. Freshening southwesterly winds. Maximum temperature 12 °C.Tonight:Cloudy with a spell of heavy rain pushing south through late evening and the early hours, followed by some clear spells. Minimum temperature 6 °C.
